I don't like buttercream -- what are my options??

by Emily Cobb Henry
(Pittsford, NY)

All right, I'll just come right out and say it: I don't like buttercream frosting. At first, I thought it was just store-made frostings that I didn't particularly enjoy (especially those on cakes coming from supermarkets or local bakeries). The frosting just always tasted so... filmy. Sugar-y. Almost grainy. And just not very flavorful or rich or *good*.

I assumed it was a result of the supermarkets just making yucky frosting. But then, as I've begun baking my own homemade cakes more often, I've discovered that it's not *their* frosting that I dislike so strongly: it's BUTTERCREAM frosting in general. No matter which recipe I try (and I've tried a bunch, including the ones on this site), I wind up with the same film-coating-the-roof-of-my-mouth, cotton-candy-sweet, not-rich frosting.

And it makes me frustrated and sad, because I *love* the rest of the cakes I've been making (the vast majority of which have been made with help from this site!), but the frosting is just BLEH most of the time. (The exceptions to this are when the frosting has flavor to it. Chocolate frostings always taste pretty good to me, and buttercream FILLINGS are yummy to me, too. But plain, vanilla buttercream? Don't like it at all.)

Here's an embarrassing tidbit: frosting that I *do* like? The canned kind. Like, that you buy at the grocery store and has Betty or Duncan or Pillsbury written on it. I absolutely ADORE canned frosting, even the vanilla varieties. And I'd like to find a homemade vanilla recipe that tastes similar... but that can also be used for piping and flower-making and letter writing, etc.

Would it help to substitute butter for all of the shortening in my frosting recipes? Would that make it richer and smoother? Or do I need to try something else entirely?

The tips and information and photos and recipes on this site have been spectacular. Thank you in advance for your help!

Comments for I don't like buttercream -- what are my options??

Average Rating starstarstarstarstar

Click here to add your own comments

Aug 19, 2009
by: Emily

Thank you so much for the ideas! I'll definitely replace the shortening with butter, and I'll check out those flavoring oils, too.


Aug 12, 2009
Buttercream Flavoring
by: Michelle (admin)

Hi Emily,

The taste will definitely improve by replacing the shortening with butter, so that you have an all butter recipe. That's actually what I use most of the time. The biggest help, however, is flavoring the buttercream. If you haven't tried these gourmet flavoring oils, you should. Adding a flavor like Bavarian Cream or Champagne to any buttercream takes it to a whole new level. They are very concentrated so you only need a few drops.

Michelle (editor)

Aug 10, 2009
Have you tried adding flavoring?
by: HotMom

Have you tried adding flavoring to your frosting? I have added almond and vanilla. It was good!

Aug 07, 2009
Other types of icing
by: Jodie

There are many other types you can get,
Whipped icing also know as (bettercreme)is one that I like and you can get in supermarket bakeries, if you ask, you could probably buy some of theirs instead of making your own... it also comes in chocolate, cookies and cream, strawberry and caramel. Hope that helps!

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Questions About Decorating a Cake.

looking for something in particular?

If you want to find something in a hurry? No Problem. Find the answers you need here:

search this site

Custom Search

still have questions?

If you still have any questions about baking, assembling or decorating a cake, ask them here!

keep the excitement going

Never be short of a great cake idea at a moment's notice.

Sign up for the "Too Nice To Slice" newsletter and get fantastic insider tips, tricks and out of the box cake decorating ideas delivered right to your inbox.




Don't worry -- your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you 'Too Nice To Slice'.

share the love

If you like what you see, why not share this site with your friends? There's always something new baking around here.